Exploring the BMW M5 Competition: A Blend of Power and Poise in a Classic Supersaloon

The BMW M5 Competition, introduced as a higher-performance variant of the F90 M5, exemplifies BMW’s strategy of enhancing its M models for additional driving excitement. While its power boost from 596bhp to 616bhp might not dramatically alter performance metrics, the refinements in handling and suspension make it a standout option in the supersaloon segment.

The core of the F90's performance lies in its twin-turbocharged 4.4-litre V8 engine, producing a robust 616bhp and maintaining a torque figure of 553lb ft. These enhancements, complemented by the optional M Driver's pack that elevates the top speed from 155mph to 190mph, underline BMW's commitment to performance. The ride height is lowered by 7mm, and the suspension is stiffened by 10%, creating an agile vehicle that remains comfortable for everyday use, though it retains its substantial physical presence.

Compared to its predecessor, the standard M5, the exterior modifications on the Competition version are subtle yet impactful. The hunkered stance provided by the lower ride height combines with uniquely designed 20-inch forged alloy wheels, contributing to an aggressive yet refined appearance. Interior upgrades are minimal but include distinctive touches, like a red starter button, signifying its performance pedigree.

With a current market price starting around £35,000 for higher mileage models, the M5 Competition represents exceptional value in the M lineup, particularly as it continues to hold its own against newer rivals like the G90 hybrid that replaced it in 2024. The F90 M5 retains its modern elegance, proving itself a timeless choice among sports sedans.

Performance Assessment: Power Meets Precision

The F90 M5 Competition is powered by the renowned S63 V8 engine, which, while exhibiting slight turbo lag, delivers exhilarating acceleration. This model boasts a 0-62mph time of just 3.3 seconds, outpacing the less powerful standard M5 by a slim 0.3 seconds. Notably, it even eclipses newer, more powerful competitors in acceleration due to the advantageous weight distribution.

Performance improvements may feel marginal on paper, yet the experience behind the wheel offers delightful engagement typical of high-performance vehicles. The Competition variant features a Sports exhaust, providing a rich, throaty roar that adds spice to the driving experience without overwhelming the senses.

The M5's eight-speed automatic transmission amplifies the engine's dynamic character, offering swift shifts that rival dual-clutch systems. However, the thrill of its performance can border on reckless when driving on public roads, as it can swiftly exceed legal speed limits. BMW has effectively managed to balance raw performance with an underlying sense of luxury, preserving a level of comfort even as you push the vehicle to its limits.

Chassis and Handling: Refined Dynamics

The Competition's enhancements are most noticeable through its chassis refinements. With a stiffer suspension setup and revised geometry, the M5 exhibits remarkable agility for a vehicle of its size. Combining new suspension components with recalibrated adaptive dampers, the M5 Competition provides a driving experience that is both engaging and solidly planted, especially while navigating through twisty road sections.

The M xDrive four-wheel-drive system permits a variety of driving modes. While it typically offers all-wheel drive for maximum traction, the option to disengage the front axle allows drivers to enjoy more traditional rear-wheel driving characteristics, blending excitement with confidence. This chassis refinement is reflective of BMW’s goal to retain the M5's reputation as a leader in the dynamic supersaloon category, despite recent competition from rivals like the Mercedes-AMG E63 S.

Interior Experience: Comfort Meets Functionality

The cabin of the F90 M5 continues to uphold BMW's reputation for quality. Although the design feels slightly dated compared to newer models, it features superior materials with a clear focus on luxury. Digital interfaces remain crisp, while the physical controls, such as the gear selector and climate knobs, are both functional and familiar. High-quality leather upholstery and supportive seating add to the overall driving comfort, further enhancing its appeal as a daily driver.

BMW has also introduced some visual cues that elevate its performance identity. The Competition model's specific design elements like forged wheels and darkened accents subtly mark its performance distinction without resorting to overbearing stylistic choices. This understated approach may garner mixed feelings, especially when compared to the more ostentatious designs of immediate competitors.

Reliability and Ownership Insights

The M5’s reliability rating is commendably strong, although some owners have experienced isolated issues, such as a fuel pump malfunction. Despite these hiccups, overall long-term ownership remains positive. It's important to consider potential operating costs, especially regarding tires. With the M5 fitted standard with Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S tires, replacements can be costly; hence, owners should anticipate the implications of the vehicle's weight on tire and brake wear.

As a long-lasting contender in the performance saloon market, the M5 Competition balances power, comfort, and style with palpable skill. While some may find the overall driving experience a touch muted compared to its rivals, its capability as a multifaceted sports sedan is hard to ignore. Those looking for a sophisticated blend of athleticism and everyday usability would be wise to consider the F90 M5 Competition as part of their options.

Stuart Gallagher, Editor-in-Chief at evo, reflected positively on the M5 experience, acknowledging its blend of comfort and capability. He emphasized that while it may not possess the raw engagement of all competitors, it encapsulates the essence of the M5 lineage, marking it as a strong choice in the evolving landscape of high-performance saloons.